What is Deaf Gain?

What is Deaf Gain?

Understanding the World Through a Different Lens/What is Deaf Gain?

What is Deaf Gain?/ Deafness is often viewed as a disability, a loss of the sense of hearing. However, the Deaf community is increasingly advocating for a different perspective: Deaf Gain. This concept challenges the traditional narrative and celebrates the unique strengths and contributions of Deaf culture and ways of experiencing the world.

1. Deaf culture and identity

A World Shaped by Sight: Unveiling Deaf Culture and Identity

Deaf culture is a vibrant and dynamic world, rich with its own language, traditions, and values. It’s not simply the absence of sound, but a distinct and thriving community built around a unique way of experiencing the world.

More Than Just Hearing Loss:

For many Deaf individuals, deafness isn’t a disability, but rather a cultural identity. They view themselves as a linguistic minority, with sign language as their native tongue. Deaf culture fosters a strong sense of belonging and shared experiences, creating a powerful sense of community.

The Power of Sign Language:

Sign language isn’t simply a way to represent spoken language visually. It’s a complex and expressive language in its own right, with its own grammar, syntax, and nuances. It allows for rich communication, humor, and storytelling, forming the cornerstone of Deaf culture.

Beyond Communication: A Distinct Way of Life:

Deaf culture extends far beyond communication. It encompasses art forms like visual poetry and dance, social norms, and even humor that thrives on the visual and physical aspects of expression. Deaf schools and social events create spaces where this culture flourishes and traditions are passed down.

Challenges and Resilience:

The Deaf community faces its share of challenges. Communication barriers and societal biases can create obstacles in education, employment, and social interactions. However, the Deaf community is known for its resilience, resourcefulness, and advocacy for inclusion.

A Bridge Between Worlds:

As society strives for greater inclusivity, understanding Deaf culture is vital. Here are some ways to bridge the gap:

  • Learn basic sign language: This opens doors for communication and fosters respect.
  • Challenge assumptions: Rethink deafness as a loss, and embrace it as a unique cultural identity.
  • Seek out Deaf-owned businesses and organizations: Support the Deaf community and experience its richness firsthand.

Celebrating Diversity:

Deaf culture is an invaluable part of the human experience. It enriches our understanding of communication, community, and the diverse tapestry of human identity. By recognizing and appreciating Deaf culture, we create a more inclusive world where everyone can thrive.

2. Benefits of deafness

Reframing the Narrative: Exploring the Benefits of Deafness

Deafness, often perceived solely as a disability, carries a rich and vibrant culture with unique strengths and perspectives. The concept of “Deaf Gain” goes beyond simply overcoming challenges; it celebrates the advantages and contributions of the Deaf community. Let’s explore some of the benefits associated with deafness.

Beyond Hearing: A World of Visual Communication

  • Sign Language: A Rich and Expressive Language: Sign language isn’t simply a way to represent spoken language. It’s a complex and nuanced visual language with its own grammar, syntax, and cultural significance. Deaf individuals who use sign language have a powerful tool for communication and expression.
  • Visual Acuity and Spatial Awareness: Studies suggest that some Deaf individuals develop heightened visual-spatial processing skills. This can enhance focus, visual memory, and the ability to perceive details in their environment.

Building a Strong Community and Identity

  • Resilience and Resourcefulness: The Deaf community fosters a strong sense of belonging and support. Overcoming communication barriers and navigating a hearing world builds resilience and problem-solving skills.
  • Unique Worldview and Innovation: Deaf individuals often approach situations from a different perspective, leading to innovative solutions and contributions in various fields. From technology like video conferencing to advancements in sign language education, the Deaf community has a rich history of innovation.

Unveiling the Creative Potential:

  • Visual Thinking and Artistic Expression: The visual nature of Deaf communication can translate into a unique artistic perspective. Many Deaf artists excel in visual mediums like painting, sculpture, and filmmaking.
  • Fullness of Life and Cultural Identity: Deafness is an integral part of Deaf culture, not a deficit. A vibrant Deaf community offers a rich tapestry of traditions, festivals, and social interactions that contribute to a full and meaningful life.

It’s Not Just About Overcoming Challenges

The focus on Deaf Gain acknowledges the challenges of hearing loss but emphasizes the unique strengths and contributions of the Deaf community. It’s about recognizing the value of a different way of experiencing and interacting with the world.

A World of Opportunity:

By understanding and appreciating Deaf Gain, we can foster a more inclusive society. This means providing equal opportunities for Deaf individuals, developing accessible communication methods, and celebrating the rich cultural contributions of the Deaf community.

Let’s move beyond viewing deafness solely as a disability. Let’s embrace Deaf Gain and celebrate the unique strengths and perspectives that come with being Deaf.

3. Advantages of sign language

  • Beyond Words: Unveiling the Advantages of Sign Language

Sign language is often seen as a way for people who are deaf or hard of hearing to communicate. But its benefits extend far beyond that. Sign language is a rich and expressive visual language with unique advantages for both deaf and hearing individuals.

A World of Expression:

Sign language isn’t just hand gestures mimicking spoken words. It’s a complete language with its own grammar, syntax, and vocabulary. Sign language allows for a nuanced and expressive way to communicate emotions, ideas, and stories through facial expressions, body language, and hand movements.

Advantages for Deaf and Hard of Hearing Individuals:

  • Accessibility and Inclusivity: For those with hearing loss, sign language provides a natural and accessible form of communication, fostering social interaction and participation in all aspects of life.
  • Cognitive Benefits: Studies suggest that sign language can enhance visual-spatial processing and memory, potentially benefiting cognitive development in deaf children.
  • Stronger Identity and Community: Sign language serves as a cornerstone of Deaf culture, fostering a sense of belonging and connection within the Deaf community.

Advantages for Hearing Individuals:

  • Enhanced Communication Skills: Learning sign language can improve communication skills in general, encouraging active listening and visual attentiveness.
  • Breaking Down Barriers: Sign language allows hearing individuals to connect with the Deaf community, fostering inclusivity and understanding.
  • Cognitive Flexibility: Studies suggest that learning sign language can enhance cognitive flexibility and the ability to think in new ways.
  • Lifelong Learning Opportunity: Learning sign language is a rewarding journey that opens doors to new cultures, perspectives, and ways of thinking.

Unlocking Potential:

Sign language isn’t just about replacing spoken language; it’s about adding a new dimension to communication. Its advantages reach far beyond the Deaf community, offering benefits for everyone who chooses to explore this rich and expressive language.

By recognizing the advantages of sign language, we can create a more inclusive and communicative world for everyone.

Deaf Gain movement

Deaf Gain: A Movement Redefining Deafness

For generations, deafness has been viewed primarily as a disability, a loss of the sense of hearing. However, the Deaf community is challenging this view with the concept of Deaf Gain. This movement celebrates the unique strengths, cultural richness, and contributions of Deaf individuals. Let’s delve deeper into the heart of the Deaf Gain movement.

Shifting the Narrative:

The Deaf Gain movement seeks to shift the focus from what Deaf people lack (hearing) to what they gain from their unique sensory experience. It acknowledges the challenges of deafness but emphasizes the strengths and advantages that come with Deaf culture and ways of communication.

Beyond Disability:

While Deaf Gain doesn’t deny the challenges of hearing loss, it promotes a more nuanced understanding. Deaf individuals develop incredible visual-spatial skills, fostering a distinct way of interacting with the world. Their strong sense of community fosters resilience and innovation.

The Power of Sign Language:

Sign language plays a central role in Deaf Gain. It’s not simply a way to represent spoken language, but a rich, complex form of communication in its own right. Sign language utilizes facial expressions, body language, and hand movements to convey meaning and emotion. This visual language fosters a unique perspective and fosters a vibrant Deaf culture.

Innovation and Problem-Solving:

The Deaf community has a long history of innovation. From the development of hearing aids and assistive technologies to advancements in sign language education, Deaf individuals have approached challenges with a unique perspective, leading to creative solutions.

Contributions to Society:

Deaf Gain highlights the valuable contributions of Deaf individuals to society. From artists and educators to scientists and entrepreneurs, Deaf people enrich the world with their unique talents and perspectives.

A Call for Inclusion:

The Deaf Gain movement advocates for a more inclusive world. It calls for removing communication barriers and creating opportunities for Deaf individuals to thrive. This includes promoting early access to sign language, providing equal access to education and employment, and fostering a greater understanding of Deaf culture.

The Future of Deaf Gain:

The Deaf Gain movement is constantly evolving. With ongoing research, technological advancements, and greater societal understanding, the future is bright for the Deaf community. As we move towards a more inclusive world, appreciating the strengths and contributions of Deafness is paramount.

  • Redefining disability

Redefining Disability: Beyond Limitations, Embracing Strengths

For centuries, disability has been viewed through a medical lens, focusing on limitations and deficits. However, a powerful movement is redefining disability, shifting the focus towards celebrating the unique strengths and capabilities of people with disabilities.

From Deficit to Difference:

The traditional model of disability frames it as a problem to be solved or a barrier to overcome. This approach often leads to a sense of pity or dependence. The redefinition movement argues that disability is a form of human difference, not a deviation from the norm. People with disabilities experience the world differently, and with the right support and inclusive environments, they can thrive.

The Power of Identity:

The disability rights movement emphasizes the importance of disability pride. People with disabilities are not defined solely by their impairments. They are individuals with diverse identities, talents, and aspirations. Embracing disability as part of one’s identity fosters self-acceptance and empowers individuals to advocate for themselves.

The Social Model of Disability:

A key concept in redefining disability is the social model. This model argues that it’s not the impairment itself, but societal barriers that create disability. For example, a person who uses a wheelchair may not be disabled in a barrier-free environment with accessible ramps and doorways. The social model emphasizes the need to remove these barriers to create a more inclusive and equitable world.

Beyond Accessibility:

Redefining disability goes beyond just physical accessibility. It’s about ensuring access to information, communication, and participation in all aspects of society. This includes promoting inclusive education, employment opportunities, and social spaces where everyone feels welcome and valued.

Celebrating Strengths and Achievements:

The new narrative around disability highlights the remarkable accomplishments of individuals with disabilities. From athletes like Paralympic champions to artists, scientists, and entrepreneurs, people with disabilities are breaking barriers and achieving excellence in all fields.

The Road to a More Inclusive Future:

Redefining disability is not just a semantic shift; it’s a call for social change. By embracing diversity, removing barriers, and celebrating the strengths of people with disabilities, we can create a world where everyone has the opportunity to reach their full potential.

  • Sensory diversity and communication

Beyond Words: Exploring Sensory Diversity and Communication

The world is a symphony of sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and textures. But how we experience these sensations can vary greatly. While hearing is often considered the primary mode of communication, a rich tapestry of sensory experiences exists beyond the spoken word.

A Spectrum of Senses:

Each of our senses plays a unique role in shaping our perception of the world. Here’s a glimpse into some sensory experiences:

  • Visual: For sighted individuals, vision is the dominant sense, providing information about shape, color, distance, and movement.
  • Auditory: Hearing allows us to perceive sounds, including speech, music, and environmental cues.
  • Tactile: Touch helps us navigate our surroundings, perceive textures, and experience physical interaction.
  • Olfactory: Smell plays a crucial role in memory, emotion, and even taste perception.
  • Gustatory: Taste allows us to distinguish flavors and enjoy the experience of eating.

Beyond the Obvious:

While these five senses are the most commonly recognized, there are others that contribute to our overall sensory experience. These include:

  • Proprioception: This sense gives us awareness of our body’s position in space and the movement of our limbs.
  • Vestibular: The vestibular system helps us maintain balance and spatial orientation.
  • Interoception: This internal sense provides information about our body’s internal state, like hunger or thirst.

Communication Beyond Words:

Our diverse sensory experiences influence how we communicate. Here are some ways communication transcends spoken language:

  • Sign Language: Visual languages like sign language offer a rich and expressive means of communication for Deaf and hard-of-hearing communities.
  • Tactile Communication: People who are deafblind may use touch-based communication methods like Braille or Signed Exact English (SEE).
  • Nonverbal Communication: Facial expressions, gestures, and body language play a significant role in communication across cultures and abilities.

Embracing Sensory Diversity:

In a world that often prioritizes spoken language and auditory experiences, understanding sensory diversity is crucial. Here’s how we can embrace this:

  • Accessibility: Creating inclusive environments that cater to various sensory needs is essential. This includes providing visual aids, offering alternative communication methods, and being mindful of lighting and noise levels.
  • Appreciation: Recognizing and appreciating the strengths of different sensory experiences fosters a more inclusive society.
  • Lifelong Learning: Continuously educating ourselves about sensory diversity allows us to better understand and interact with individuals who experience the world differently.

A World of Communication:

Sensory diversity enriches the tapestry of human communication. By embracing these variations and fostering inclusive communication practices, we can create a world where everyone can connect, share ideas, and thrive.

Strengths of the Deaf community

Beyond Silence: Celebrating the Strengths of the Deaf Community

The Deaf community, a vibrant and diverse group united by shared experiences and language, offers a unique perspective on the world. While deafness is often seen as a disability, the Deaf community has long championed the concept of Deaf Gain, emphasizing the strengths and contributions that come with this unique identity.

Strength Through Language:

  • Sign Language: A Rich and Expressive Form: Sign language isn’t simply a way to communicate spoken language visually. It’s a complete and complex language with its own grammar, syntax, and cultural nuances. The visual nature of sign language allows for a high degree of expressiveness and fosters a strong sense of community.
  • Visual Communication and Problem-Solving: Deaf individuals often develop heightened visual-spatial processing skills. This can be a valuable asset in various aspects of life, from problem-solving and critical thinking to artistic expression and innovation.

Resilience and Ingenuity:

  • Overcoming Obstacles: Members of the Deaf community face communication barriers in a world dominated by sound. Yet, they have developed a strong sense of resilience and resourcefulness. This fosters a problem-solving mentality and the ability to find creative solutions to challenges.
  • Technological Innovation: The Deaf community has been a driving force behind advancements in communication technology, including video relay services and real-time captioning. Their unique perspective on communication has led to advancements that benefit everyone, not just the Deaf community.

Community and Identity:

  • Strong Social Bonds: Shared experiences and a common language create a strong sense of community within the Deaf world. This close-knit social network provides support, understanding, and a sense of belonging for its members.
  • Cultural Richness: The Deaf community boasts a rich and vibrant culture with its own traditions, values, and artistic expressions. Sign language poetry, visual arts, and a thriving theater scene are just some examples of the cultural treasures that flourish within the Deaf community.

Advocacy and Inclusion:

  • Breaking Down Barriers: The Deaf community actively advocates for inclusion and accessibility in education, employment, and social settings. Their efforts have led to significant progress in closing the communication gap and creating a more inclusive world.
  • Role Models and Inspiration: Deaf individuals are achieving success in various fields, from science and technology to arts and politics. These role models serve as a source of inspiration for younger generations, demonstrating the many possibilities open to members of the Deaf community.

The strengths of the Deaf community extend far beyond overcoming challenges. Their unique perspective, resilience, and cultural richness are valuable assets that contribute to the diversity and vibrancy of our society. Recognizing and celebrating these strengths is essential as we strive towards a more inclusive and equitable world.

  • Visual-spatial thinking in deafness

Seeing the World Differently: Visual-Spatial Thinking in Deafness

For most people, hearing plays a significant role in how we perceive and interact with the world. But for individuals who are Deaf or hard of hearing, their primary mode of communication and experience is visual. This has led researchers to explore a fascinating concept: visual-spatial thinking in deafness.

Beyond Silence: A Different Sensory World

Deafness alters the way the brain processes information. Since auditory input is limited or absent, the brain dedicates more resources to visual processing. This can lead to the development of enhanced visual-spatial skills in some Deaf individuals.

What is Visual-Spatial Thinking?

Visual-spatial thinking refers to the ability to mentally process and manipulate visual information, including spatial relationships, shapes, and objects.

Potential Advantages for the Deaf Community:

Studies have shown that Deaf individuals may excel in certain aspects of visual-spatial processing compared to their hearing counterparts. Here are some potential benefits:

  • Stronger Mental Imagery: Research suggests that Deaf individuals may be better at creating and manipulating mental images, which can be helpful in various tasks like problem-solving and remembering information.
  • Enhanced Spatial Reasoning: The ability to understand and navigate spatial relationships may be more developed in some Deaf individuals. This could benefit activities like map reading, mental rotation of objects, and visualizing 3D structures.
  • Visual Attention and Perception: Deafness may lead to increased focus on visual cues, potentially enhancing visual attention and the ability to detect details in their environment.

It’s Not a Universal Advantage:

It’s important to note that these are potential benefits, not guaranteed strengths for every Deaf individual. Several factors, including access to sign language and educational opportunities, can influence the development of visual-spatial skills.

Beyond the Lab: Real-World Applications

Enhanced visual-spatial thinking can translate into practical advantages for Deaf individuals. Here are some examples:

  • Success in STEM Fields: Visual-spatial skills are crucial in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. Deaf individuals with strong visual-spatial abilities may excel in these areas.
  • Artistic Expression: The visual world holds particular importance for Deaf individuals. Enhanced visual-spatial skills can contribute to artistic expression in fields like painting, sculpture, and filmmaking.
  • Spatial Navigation: Stronger spatial reasoning may benefit Deaf individuals when navigating their environment, remembering routes, and understanding maps.

A Spectrum of Abilities:

The Deaf community is diverse, and the degree of visual-spatial thinking will vary from person to person. However, understanding this concept sheds light on the unique strengths and experiences of Deaf individuals.

  • Deaf innovation and technology

Beyond Communication: Deaf Innovation and the Power of a Different Lens

The Deaf community has a rich history of innovation, driven by the need to overcome communication barriers and thrive in a world built around sound. This innovative spirit has not only led to advancements in sign language and accessibility, but has also yielded unexpected benefits for society as a whole.

Necessity as the Mother of Invention:

Throughout history, Deaf individuals have developed ingenious ways to connect and navigate a world designed for hearing people. Here are some examples:

  • Sign Language: Sign languages are complex and nuanced visual languages, not simply gestures representing spoken words. Deaf communities have developed rich sign languages that allow for full expression and communication.
  • Visual Communication Tools: From early warning systems using flashing lights to modern video relay services, Deaf individuals have pioneered technologies that transcend traditional spoken communication.
  • Technological Accessibility: From captions on television to real-time transcripts in meetings, Deaf innovation has pushed for advancements in technology that benefit everyone who relies on visual information.

Beyond Communication: A Different Perspective

Deafness isn’t just about the absence of sound; it’s a unique way of experiencing the world. This different perspective has led to unexpected innovations:

  • Visual Thinking: Research suggests that some Deaf individuals exhibit stronger visual-spatial processing skills. This can lead to innovative solutions in fields like design, engineering, and art.
  • Focus and Attention: Deaf individuals often develop heightened visual attention skills, which can be beneficial in professions requiring intense focus and detail-oriented work.
  • Problem-Solving from a Different Angle: Approaching problems from a non-traditional perspective can lead to creative solutions. Deaf innovators often bring this fresh perspective to various challenges.

A Collaborative Future:

Deaf innovation thrives on collaboration. When the Deaf community’s unique skills and perspectives are combined with those of the hearing world, the potential for groundbreaking solutions expands.

Examples of Collaboration:

  • Technology for Everyone: Innovations driven by the Deaf community’s need for accessible communication, like captions and real-time transcripts, benefit everyone who relies on visual information.
  • Inclusive Design: As accessibility becomes a priority, Deaf input is crucial in designing user-friendly products and experiences for everyone.
  • Bridging the Gap: Technological advancements like video conferencing with sign language interpretation are fostering greater communication and understanding between Deaf and hearing communities.
  1. Celebrating Deaf success stories

Beyond Silence: Celebrating the Achievements of the Deaf Community

The Deaf community boasts a rich history and a vibrant culture. Deaf individuals have made significant contributions in various fields, shattering stereotypes and proving that deafness is not a limitation but a unique way of experiencing the world. Today, we celebrate some of these inspiring Deaf success stories:

Paving the Way in Education:

  • Laurent Clerc: A pivotal figure in Deaf education, Clerc co-founded the first permanent school for the Deaf in the United States. His dedication laid the foundation for Deaf education worldwide.
  • Dr. I. King Jordan: The first Black Deaf president of Gallaudet University, a prestigious institution for the Deaf, Dr. Jordan championed accessibility and inclusion for Deaf students.

Innovation and Technology:

  • Hugh Everett: This theoretical physicist, known for the “Many-Worlds Interpretation” of quantum mechanics, was also Deaf. His groundbreaking work exemplifies the intellectual prowess within the Deaf community.
  • Robert Weitzel: A Deaf inventor, Weitzel created the first commercially successful hand-operated telegraph, showcasing the ingenuity and problem-solving skills of Deaf individuals.

Artistic Expression:

  • Nyle DiMarco: A captivating model and dancer, DiMarco became the first Deaf contestant to win “Dancing with the Stars,” inspiring millions and challenging perceptions of disability in the entertainment industry.
  • Christine Sunberg: A renowned painter and sculptor, Sunberg’s vibrant artwork showcases the power of visual communication and expression within the Deaf community.

Advocacy and Leadership:

  • Helen Keller: While not Deaf herself, Keller’s remarkable story as a deafblind woman who became a renowned advocate for disability rights serves as an inspiration to the Deaf community and beyond.
  • Lydia Callis: A prominent Deaf lawyer and activist, Callis fights for equal access and legal rights for Deaf individuals, paving the way for a more inclusive society.

These are just a few examples of the countless Deaf individuals making a difference. From education and technology to art, advocacy, and countless other fields, the Deaf community has a rich tapestry of success stories. By celebrating these achievements, we challenge stereotypes, promote inclusion, and recognize the invaluable contributions of Deafness to the world.

Looking Forward:

The future holds even greater promise for the Deaf community. With advancements in technology and increasing awareness, Deaf individuals continue to break barriers and achieve success across various fields. Recognizing and celebrating these achievements is crucial for building a more inclusive world where everyone can reach their full potential.

Deaf Gain: Beyond Absence

Deaf Gain goes beyond simply denying the challenges of hearing loss. It acknowledges them while highlighting the unique strengths and perspectives that come with being Deaf. Here are some key aspects of Deaf Gain:

  • Rich Visual Language: Sign language, the primary language of many Deaf individuals, is a complex and expressive visual language. It offers a distinct way of communicating and interacting with the world.
  • Stronger Visual Perception: Studies suggest that some Deaf individuals develop heightened visual-spatial processing skills. This can be beneficial in various aspects of life, from problem-solving to artistic expression.
  • Resilience and Community: The Deaf community has a strong sense of identity and fosters a supportive network. This can lead to increased resilience and a unique perspective on the world.
  • Innovation and Problem-Solving: Deaf individuals often approach challenges with a unique perspective, leading to innovative solutions in communication, technology, and education.

Deaf Gain: A Paradigm Shift

Deaf Gain represents a shift in how we view deafness. It’s not just about overcoming a disability, but about celebrating the strengths, contributions, and unique perspective of the Deaf community. As we move towards a more inclusive society, recognizing and understanding Deaf Gain is crucial.

References:

FAQs:

  1. What is Deaf Gain? Deaf Gain is a concept that challenges the traditional view of deafness as a disability. It focuses on the unique strengths, perspectives, and contributions of Deaf culture and ways of experiencing the world.
  2. How is Deaf Gain different from overcoming deafness? Deaf Gain doesn’t deny the challenges of hearing loss. It acknowledges them while highlighting the strengths that come with being Deaf.
  3. What are some examples of Deaf Gain? Deafness can lead to stronger visual-spatial processing skills, a vibrant sign language communication system, and a unique perspective on problem-solving.
  4. Isn’t sign language just a way to communicate for those who can’t hear? Sign language is a complex and expressive visual language with its own grammar and structure, not just a replacement for spoken language.
  5. What role does community play in Deaf Gain? The Deaf community fosters a strong sense of identity and resilience, encouraging innovation and problem-solving within a supportive network.
  6. Can Deaf people experience internal voices? Yes, Deaf individuals can have internal monologues, but they may be visual or conceptual rather than auditory in nature.
  7. Are Deaf people more creative? While there’s no guarantee, some theorize that the visual-spatial strengths and unique communication methods associated with Deafness can contribute to creativity in various fields.
  8. Does Deaf Gain mean deafness isn’t a disability? Deafness can present challenges, but Deaf Gain emphasizes the strengths and value of Deaf culture and perspectives.
  9. How can I learn more about Deaf Gain? Resources like the National Association of the Deaf (NAD), books on Deaf Gain like “Deaf Gain: Raising the Stakes for Human Diversity” by Harlan Lane, and documentaries about Deaf culture can offer valuable insights.
  10. Why is Deaf Gain important? Recognizing Deaf Gain promotes inclusivity, challenges stereotypes, and celebrates the unique contributions of the Deaf community to the world.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *